Spent Grain for Livestock Feed
By Chris Colby
Back in the mid 1990s, during a visit to my hometown, I stopped by the Sioux Falls Brewery to try their beers. As a home brewer, I was keen to glean any information about their beers and brewing process that I could. However, something else on their menu caught my eye – the burgers.
The brewery’s burgers were made of beef from a local farm, and the cattle were fed spent grains donated to the farm from the brewery. What a great idea, I thought. The brewery doesn’t have to pay to send their spent grains to a landfill, and the farmer gets free food for his livestock.
The Sioux Falls Brewery is gone now, but with the increase in the number of brewpubs and small breweries in the United States, the practice of farmers supplementing their feed with brewery spent grains (BSG) is growing.
Locating a source
Spent grains are the major waste product of the brewing process, about 85 percent of total brewery waste. Most breweries brew several times a week – if not daily – year-round, and spent grains are continuously generated. If the brewer has no way to get rid of them, he must pay for their disposal. On the other hand, if a local farmer is willing to pick them up, many brewers are happy to donate the spent grains, which can be used as animal feed. In areas of high demand for animal feed, breweries may charge a small fee.
Spent grains can often be obtained for the cost of hauling them away from the brewery. A University of Florida publication estimated that using spent grain for a portion of a farm’s animal feed made sense economically if the brewery was within 200 miles. The Brewers Association website has a feature that lets you search for breweries in any state in the U.S. or in any country.
Image Alexey Repka – Fotolia
Barley is the most abundant grain in all major styles of beer, although many beers have substantial amounts of maize, rice, wheat, or other grains. American-style Pilsners, for example, are brewed with 30 to 40 percent corn, rice, or a mixture of the two grains.
In the beer-brewing process, malted grains are crushed and soaked in hot water. This step is called the mash. During the mash phase, starches in the grains are dissolved, then transformed into simpler sugars by enzymes from the grain. The sugar-rich liquid from the mix, called wort, is drained away. This wort is then fermented and transformed into beer. The remaining grain solids are the waste product: brewery spent grains.
What’s in spent grain?
Brewery spent grains can be fed to cattle, hogs, poultry, or fish. As they are ruminants, cattle are able to utilize a good portion of the nutrients from brewery spent grains, and it is what most farmers use them for. However, spent grains are not nutritionally complete and should not be relied on as the only feed source.
When still wet, spent grains are initially between 77 and 81 percent water by weight. The remaining solid matter is comprised of fiber, protein and other associated organic matter. The fiber includes the husk, pericarp, and seed coat of the malted barley grains. The fibrous husk material constitutes about 70 percent of the dry weight of brewery spent grains. During mashing, the starchy interior of the grain has been dissolved and rinsed away.
The fiber is digestible by ruminants, and most spent grain is used to feed cattle. However, brewery spent grains can be fed to poultry if enzymes are added to help degrade the fiber to make them digestible.
Between 20 and 30 percent of the dry weight of brewery spent grains is protein, and 36 percent of this is rumen degradable in cattle. Although some soluble protein is leached and drained during the brewing process, insoluble proteins and some residual soluble proteins remain. A small amount of simple sugar, mostly maltose, remains in spent grain, along with 7 to 10 percent crude fat.
Spent grain contains a lot of minor components that are nutritionally important, including essential amino acids and non-essential amino acids. When supplemented with an outside nitrogen source (such as urea), brewery spent grains can provide all the amino acids cattle require.
Spent grains also contain a wealth of vitamins and minerals. Cattle require more calcium than spent grains supply, so some supplemental calcium is required if spent grains are used as a significant proportion of the cattle’s feed. If not supplemented, growth rate could be slowed.
Some have even examined the possibility of incorporating spent grains into human diets, specifically via cookies. The authors of the study found that spent grains are rich in hydroxycinnamic acid and phenolic acids, which may have anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anti-cancer properties.
Image Chris Colby
Brewery spent grains contain 71 to 75 percent total digestible nutrients (TDN). For comparison, corn feed yields 88 to 90 percent TDN. Given that brewery spent grains are often free, or obtained at a cost far below normal animal feed, they are an attractive source of nutrition for livestock producers.
Some studies have shown benefits beyond cattle. Carp fish whose diets were supplemented with spent grains showed faster weight gain than carp fed their regular diet. In dairy cattle, supplementary spent grains increased milk yield, milkfat percentage, and the amount of milk solids. In correct proportion to their normal feed, cows increased their feed intake, experienced quicker weight gain, and achieved higher body weight. Part of the increase in feed intake may be due to the water in the grains. In general, animals tend to prefer food with some moisture content to dry feed.
The effects of spent grain consumption as hog feed are not quite as impressive. In hogs, increased amounts of dried spent grains correlated with lower feed intake and a longer time to reach slaughter weight. As hogs are not ruminants, and can’t digest fiber very well, the primary value of spent grains in their diet is the protein content.
A drawback to brewery spent grains is that they must be used quickly or they will go bad and lose their nutritional value. They will begin to smell after only a day of warm weather. As such, they should be used within a few days of pickup. Drying the grains to below 12 percent moisture will help slow their spoilage. However, this is usually done in rotating drum devices, and can be costly compared the value of the grain.
On the plus side, most breweries brew every day, or almost so. If you find a brewery willing to work with you, you will have a steady supply of the material. Some farmers have extended the usefulness of spent grains by preserving them with benzoic acid, formic acid, or potassium sorbate. In one case, applying 30 percent beet molasses with 0.3 percent potassium sorbate worked well to preserve wet spent grains, so long as they were held in plastic bags with minimal headspace. Spent grains are usually stored in plastic bags, sealed to keep out as much oxygen as possible. Leaving bags open contributes to mold growth and decreased palatability.
Image Chris Colby
Spent grains are not nutritionally complete, so they are used as a supplement to regular feed. Animals fed spent grains will likely benefit from supplementary nitrogen and calcium.
For cattle, the University of Florida recommends 30 to 50 pounds (wet weight) spent grains per day, and 20 pounds (wet weight) per day maximum for calves. This corresponds to 8 to 13 pounds per day dry weight for cattle and 2 to 5 pounds dry weight per day for calves. A study in which various proportions of spent grains to regular feed were compared found that 15 to 30 percent of the diet being spent grains led to the fastest weight gain. In chickens, supplementing their regular feed with 10 to 20 percent dried spent grains was found to be the most effective.
Spent grains are the major waste in the brewing process. With feed being the major cost associated with raising cattle, utilizing spent grains – turning beer ingredients into beef – proves beneficial to both brewer and farmer. With some additional supplementing, spent grains can be used as a significant portion of an animal’s diet. So, if you’re looking for a source of inexpensive feed, raise a glass at your local brewpub or tap room, then ask to speak to the brewer.
Chris Colby is an avid gardener who lives in Bastrop, Texas, with his wife and their cats. His academic background is in biology – a Ph.D. from Boston University – but his main interest is in brewing beer.
Harvest Quality Livestock Forage
Good soil and optimum harvest times can improve livestock forage in your pastures.
Homegrown Garden Amendments
Use these amendment strategies throughout your plants’ growth cycle to promote healthy development.
A Taste of Summer: Growing the Best Sweet Corn
From planting to harvesting and everything in between, learn how to grow summer’s signature stalk.