If a Tree Falls: Tree-cutting Techniques


Tags: trees,

A photo of Steve DautNow that we’re supplementing our heat with wood, I’ve been spending a fair amount of time cutting and hauling wood. Not only have I been cleaning up the dead trees on our property, but last weekend a friend of mine and I made a deal with the place I work to clean up a couple of standing oaks that died two or three summers ago.

Until recently, I didn’t cut wood much and had only felled a handful of trees in my life. They always fell exactly where I wanted them to, so I felt pretty cocky about my skills until I was taking down a 30-foot pine tree about five years back. This was when I still lived in the City, and I had just gotten the tree to the point of no return, cutting-wise, when a sudden gust of wind came out of the wrong direction, the big crack happened that lets you know the tree is down, and it was fixing to fall on my neighbor’s fence, yard, and maybe even his house. Fortunately, the tree was right beside my garage and I had propped a ladder up to the roof, because, well, heck- I can’t even remember why. But at any rate, I was able to get up beside the tree with a rope, get Sue out to help, and brought it back upwind to fall where it was supposed to go in the first place. The experience taught me not to take anything for granted.

Since then, I’ve worked with a few tree cutters and it seems to me there are a couple of approaches on how to get gravity to work in the right direction. The first, I'll call the natural approach. I was with a professional tree harvester in the woods out at the farm. Sue’s mom Bee had hired him to thin out some of the canopy trees to let the newer growth get enough light. Once he found a tree he was going to take out, he’d study it to figure out which way it wanted to go. Then he’d make a tiny little notch on that side- maybe a quarter of the way in, at most. He’d finish with a horizontal cut from the other side, and would have it cut all the way through and out of the way before the tree started falling. At the time, I figured if you’re doing it for a living, you want to expend as little effort as possible getting the things down.

I had to modify that position recently. Our current neighbor to the south also clears out trees for a living, and he takes what I’ll call the shock and awe approach. I’ve had this dead tree hanging out over my pond. It had fallen so far over that the top branches were actually touching the pond. I mentioned it to the neighbor, assuming that the only option would be to wait until the pond froze and drop it on the ice. He said he had a cable and winch hookup that could put 40,000 pounds of torque on a tree and drop it wherever he wanted it to go, and I could imagine him ripping the thing out by the roots, sideways. I’ve had a close call or two with high tension cables, so I waited until the pond froze and dropped the tree on the ice.

Last weekend, my friend used an approach somewhere in between the two when we were taking down the first oak at the place where I work. It also was along a pond bank, but this was a big, mature oak. It wasn’t really clear if the ice would hold the thing, but there was only about a fifteen foot wide swath where we could drop the thing and avoid the ice, shed, and the fence that enclosed the pond, and to top it off, the tree seemed to be leaning in exactly the wrong direction. My friend took a big notch about waist high. It was more than a third of the trunk, with a horizontal cut at the bottom and a high angle on the top cut. The back cut was probably 30 degrees, coming down into the notch, and when he had two of inches of cut left, he put a couple of wedges into the back cut and drove them in with a maul. He cut it down until the tree was starting to wobble, pulled the saw out and finished the job by driving in the wedges. I swear he could have laid a dime on the ground where it was going to fall.

The interesting thing is that each of these guys knew just what they were doing and talked like their way was the best one they had found. I never would have guessed there were as many different approaches to taking down a tree, and I’m sure there are a quite a few more that I haven’t seen yet. I’d like to hear from anyone out there who has a different “best” way.

6/14/2009 5:14:55 PM

I definitely agree that in tricky situations, the best approach is to let the pros do it. When we lived in town, we had a thirty-foot pine that the previous owner had planted about 5 feet from the house (they look so cool like that when they are 3 feet tall). It hung way out over our neighbor's driveway and it was also playing havock with the corner of the house so we finally called in a tree service. They showed up with this truck that had a gizmo that grabbed the trunk, cut the tree off below that, and laid the whole tree right down in the bed of the truck. Nothing like having the right tools for the job.

6/13/2009 2:47:34 PM

Striping a tree of its lower branches sure does help before downing the whole tree, The fifth tree I took down did the same thing as the second. I even cut it to fall in the direction of the wind, and the way the tree was leaning, but guess what! It still fell in the opposite direction than planned. Sometimes you can't see the twist at the top of the tree where most of the weight is. I believe that was the reason for the direction change of mine. Luckily for me the tree service company that I hired to remove my stumps offered to cut down the remaining five to come down at no extra charge. Thank God, there are still good people in this world that will go out of their way to prevent you from making a major mistake. You might inquire with your tree service co. first before taking the chance doing it yourself. They would rather have things landed in a easy spot for them to work around, and to ensure that they might offer like my guy did, to do that part for free. Good Luck.

6/13/2009 7:20:01 AM

I think big pine trees have to be the most dangerous trees to fell. With a deciduous tree, you can usually tell pretty much which way it wants to go, you can step back quickly if you need to, and once it starts to go, that's the way it's going. But pines will reverse direction if the wind catches them just right. And besides which, with all the pointy needles and dense branch structure, you can get lost in the thing unless yuou strip it for quite a ways off the ground before you start cutting it down.

Live The Good Life with GRIT!

Grit JulAug 2016At GRIT, we have a tradition of respecting the land that sustains rural America. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing to GRIT through our automatic renewal savings plan. By paying now with a credit card, you save an additional $6 and get 6 issues of GRIT for only $16.95 (USA only).

Or, Bill Me Later and send me one year of GRIT for just $22.95!

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters