10 Soil Indicators for Your Vegetable Garden

Ten soil indicators that could signal that your plants are in trouble.

| September/October 2011

Healthy Vegetable Garden

Maintaining healthy soil pays off in the end.

David Liebman

The fun of gardening can quickly turn to frustration if a row of squash fails or your tomato plants produce no fruit. At some point, even the best gardeners must put on their detective hats and find out what went wrong.  While deer prints may be a dead giveaway, most gardening problems stem from less-obvious problems with soil health. Luckily, poor soil leaves clues that are easy to spot with practice. Gardening experts have compiled 10 warning signs of trouble in the garden. Knowing these, you can troubleshoot your own garden.

Do the numbers

Doing a soil test is as important to gardening as getting a survey done before you begin building a house. A good soil test will tell you the pH balance of your soil, as well as its levels of key nutrients. Troubleshooting soil health is easiest to do before anything is planted, says John Jemison, water quality and soil specialist at the University of Maine Cooperative Extension in Orono.

“Gardeners really need to do a soil test as a first step because then they have a plan,” he says. 

Not all soil tests are created equal, however. Susan Littlefield, horticulture editor with the National Gardening Association in South Burlington, Vermont, has found wide variables between soil tests. While there are affordable DIY soil tests on the market, Littlefield recommends getting your soil tested with a professional tester or through a cooperative extension office before taking action. For more, see “Know Your Soil” on Page 64.

Standing water

A garden should drain. If water pools in your garden long after a hard rain, that’s a problem. 

Nowhere is this problem more apparent than in the moist Pacific Northwest. Falaah Jones, an environmental educator with Seattle Tilth, gets many calls from gardeners with soggy crops through the organization’s helpline (206-633-0224). Eager gardeners plant too early in the wet spring in poorly drained ground, only to watch their seedlings die.

mother earth news fair


Feb. 17-18, 2018
Belton, Texas

More than 150 workshops, great deals from more than 200 exhibitors, off-stage demos, inspirational keynotes, and great food!