Round Barns: Preserving a Truly American Tradition

Efficient and inexpensive, round barns came too late.


| January/February 2011



Shelburne Museum

Shelburne Museum, in Vermont, is home to this traditional round barn.

iStockphoto.com/Scott Eagle

Once reviled as ridiculous, the American round barn’s economical volume-enclosing efficiency was never able to attract widespread adopters, despite the efforts of many state boards of agriculture. Evolving from early polygonal designs, round barns captured George Washington’s fascination for their thrift in construction and convenience of use. Shakers are said to have built the first true round barn in western Massachusetts using stone. Late turn-of-the-19th-century dairymen in Wisconsin and Illinois were among the few enthusiastic adopters.  

Today, round barns tend to be anomalous icons of America’s agricultural past. Our fascination has placed many such structures on historic registers across the United States, but many others remain tucked away, the unsung heroes of an agrarian age long past.  

Culture clash 

Round barns didn’t catch on in part because they represented a change that farmers and ranchers simply weren’t able to accept. Tight ethnic agricultural communities more or less dictated the proper, if not moral, style of barn in a particular region. In some places, farmers might be shunned or given limited access to certain necessary facilities or markets if they built so radically different a barn. In other places, they might simply have been thought a fool.  

In the Kansas Board of Agriculture’s 18th Biennial Report, the Illinois Agriculture College is credited with completing so careful an analysis of the construction and use efficiencies associated with round barns that it seemed obvious that the structure was indeed the innovative choice.   

Agricultural innovation 

The Historic Round Barn of Gettysburg, in Pennsylvania, is one well-preserved example of the type. Today, the Knouse family owns the structure and runs a farmers’ market from the location. Kyle Knouse says the round barn, which is unique to Adams County, was built by the Noah Sheely family to replace a conventional barn that burned to the ground.  

“The Sheelys were known to be very innovative. (Their) son, Daniel, saw a round barn (near) Hershey, Pennsylvania, and convinced his father and brother that this is what they needed. The blueprints of the barn came from information they received from the Illinois Agriculture Experiment Station and the architect, Morris Rhodes, from Chambersburg, Pennsylvania,” Knouse says. “The barn at that time was used to house about 50 head of cattle and about 16 mules or horses.”  

jim ferland
4/28/2013 7:53:53 PM

The round stone barn mentioned at the beginning of the article is located at the Shaker Village in Hancock, Massachusetts near my hometown of Pittsfield. The barn was fully restored in the 1960's with the blacksmith work - fabrication of all the iron strap hinges, latches, etc. were provided by a close friend of my family for the restoration project. That barn has, since my youth, been an inspiration to me to live a Mother Earth life. Everyone who has the opportunity should see it and the entire restored village. By the way - The Shakers at Hancock Village invented vegetable garden seeds in packets as we know them today.


deansmith32
4/28/2013 5:24:53 PM

In Gagetown,Michigan there is a wonderfully restored octagon barn. It was saved and preserved by group of barn lovers and sensed the value of keeping this bit of American farm life. It is now a museum and center for multiple activities. It was built by the Monroe Brothers.


jenny
2/16/2011 11:04:18 PM

I grew up in Fulton Co. Indiana, where there were several round barns. Most have not been kept up and are now gone. One is now part of the county museum. I have always loved the old barns, all styles, and it saddens me to see them not taken care of and left to fall down. I understand the expense of the upkeep to some it is not worth it, so I really enjoy hearing about someone taking the time to care for and restore an old barn, especially the round barns.


michelle in ok
2/16/2011 6:53:28 PM

There is a beautiful round barn in Arcadia, Oklahoma; right on HWY 66. It's set up as a tourist stop and is open for anyone who wants to look.


michelle in ok
2/16/2011 6:46:44 PM

There is a beautiful round barn in Arcadia, Oklahoma; right on HWY 66. It's set up as a tourist stop and is open for anyone who wants to look.


cheryl guffey
2/10/2011 9:42:44 PM

Where I grew up in Elko-New Market, Minnesota, a neighbor of ours had a round barn. It is still there though recently, the roof has caved on one side, when I visited there this past November, probably from the snow, not sure. I am hoping it can be saved as it is a rarity these days. My husband and I are working towards an agrarian way of life and I pray the government will stay out of our lives enough that we can actually live that life without being policed of the food we grow. We have purchased heirloom seeds in anticipation of this day, but for now we will grow a huge garden in town.


merry jackson
1/6/2011 7:41:20 PM

There use to be an octagon barn in Tarkio, MO. David Rankin had it build years ago. It has burned down but there are pictures of it in the libaray at Rock Port MO. He was one of the biggest farmers in three counties. David also helped build Tarkio Collage.






mother earth news fair

MOTHER EARTH NEWS FAIR

Feb. 17-18, 2018
Belton, Texas

More than 150 workshops, great deals from more than 200 exhibitors, off-stage demos, inspirational keynotes, and great food!

LEARN MORE